This post may contain affiliate links which means if you purchase we may receive a small commission at no additional cost to you
I remember when my son was in middle school, I made these Creepy frozen eyeballs. My son loved them and enjoyed playing tricks on others with them. But he was concerned he would have to eat them. HA! Nope, he could have if he has wished but it was not required. In fact, I’m not sure how these flavors would go together, and not willing to find out right now.
They are kinda creepy huh! And so easy with edible items you may already have in your fridge. I don’t freeze them inside ice cubes like some do because I think that round scary frozen eyeball floating in your favorite beverage is more authentic and freaky. But I do freeze the eyeball since it will stay together easier and actually serves the second purpose of chilling your beverage.
Scary Frozen Eyeballs for Creepy Halloween Beverages
- Red Radishes
- Green Olives with Pimentos
Cut off the stem and root ends off each radish
Use a small knife such as a paring knife to scrape off most of the red skin of each radish and leave just enough red to give the radish a veined appearance.
Rinse the radishes
Cut the olives in half
Either use a very small melon baller or use your knife to carve out a hole into the end of each radish large enough for the 1/2 olive
Place a 1/2 olive, cut side out, into the hole
Place on an ice tray or any container so the eyeballs stand up and place in freezer. After the eyeballs are frozen, place them in a ziplock freezer bag until ready to use
Place either one or two in a glass of your favorite beverage or use several in a punch bowl for a “chilling” effect!
If you Enjoyed these Halloween Creepy Ice Cube Eyeballs then:
Love Cast Iron?
Join us and receive "How to Season and Care for Cast Iron" ebook and weekly email newlestters to what's cooking at the Ranch.